How to Build a Human

A forensics company tells cops it can use DNA to predict a suspect’s face. Scientists worry the tool will deepen racial bias.

Credit: Image by Peace,love,happiness from Pixabay
Jordan Smith
Jordan Smith
Jordan Smith
The Intercept
Jordan Smith is a state and national award-winning investigative journalist based in Austin, Texas. She has covered criminal justice for more than 20 years and, during...
- The Intercept
Viewed 4 times
3 Min Read
This article has been archived, so the information may no longer be relevant and images or other features may no longer be working.

As a teenager, Dr. Susan Walsh loved the TV show “The X-Files.” She was particularly drawn to the character of Dana Scully, a hyper-rational doctor-cum-FBI agent who brought a scientist’s skepticism to investigations of paranormal phenomena and deployed her medical training to determine cause of death for the show’s victims.

The fact that Scully used science to solve problems and pursue justice intrigued Walsh. She wanted to explore a career in forensics but was on the fence about how to do it. Should she go into law enforcement? Become a scientist? The show helped her to decide. She loved the science. “It did start with Scully, if I’m being honest,” she said.

Walsh studied biochemistry and, while working on her master’s degree in DNA profiling, she happened onto a research paper that caught her attention. Australian scientists had found DNA markers corresponding to eye color, and Walsh began to wonder whether those techniques could be applied to criminal investigations.

Susan walsh portrait
Susan Walsh has devoted her career to researching whether DNA can be used to predict someone’s face — but she doesn’t think the science is there yet. (Indiana University Indianapolis School of Science)

If crime-scene DNA could be analyzed for markers that relate to physical appearance, Walsh suspected that could help investigators identify suspects — and take crime fighting to a new level.

“Oh wow, that’s so cool that we’ll one day be able to predict what people look like,” using DNA, she thought. “In an application of a forensic setting, that’s amazing.”

That was 2005. Today, Walsh is at the top of her field. An assistant professor in the School of Science at Indiana University Indianapolis, she runs a lab researching what is now known as forensic DNA phenotyping, or FDP. Walsh has worked on locating genes related to eye, hair, and skin color and has built an open-source tool for people, including in law enforcement, who want to use DNA to predict those traits. She has also investigated connections between DNA markers and the appearance of various facial features, known as facial morphology.

See more of our content in Google search results!

Share This Article
Jordan Smith
The Intercept
Jordan Smith is a state and national award-winning investigative journalist based in Austin, Texas. She has covered criminal justice for more than 20 years and, during that time, has developed a reputation as a resourceful and dogged reporter with a talent for analyzing complex social and legal issues. She is regarded as one of the best investigative reporters in Texas. A longtime staff writer for the Austin Chronicle, her work has also appeared in The Nation, the Crime Report, and Salon, among other places.