A new report from Uncloseted Media and GAY TIMES pulls back the curtain on a small but vocal group of MAGA gay men who continue to support Donald Trump, even as his administration systematically dismantles LGBTQ+ protections.
What emerges is a portrait of isolation, rationalization, and a worldview shaped more by grievance against the Left than by any concrete benefit offered by the Right.
A Shrinking Minority
The numbers tell the story plainly. Roughly 83 percent of queer men vote Democratic, according to Pew Research. Fewer than one in five LGBTQ voters cast a ballot for Trump in 2024.
That makes gay Trump supporters a distinct minority within their own community, and the reasons for that are not mysterious.
Since January 2025, the Trump administration has terminated more than $1 billion in HIV-related research grants and removed the Pride flag from the Stonewall National Monument (they recently reversed their decision and returned the Pride flag to the Monument).
The administration even shut down the LGBTQ-specific option on the 988 youth suicide hotline.
These aren’t abstract culture war skirmishes. They’re concrete policy decisions that cost lives, defund medical research, and strip visibility from a community that fought for decades to be seen.
The Personal Toll
The Uncloseted Media piece centers on three men who illustrate the loneliness of being MAGA gay men.
Evan, a 21-year-old math student in Long Island who spoke under a pseudonym, describes stuttering for 20 minutes before he could tell his boyfriend he voted for Trump.
Nick Duncan, a 43-year-old hospitality executive in Miami, says he has lost all of his gay friends over his politics and no longer feels safe attending Pride events.
Chris Doane, 56, remains closeted to his family in Texas, where he was raised to view Democrats as enemies of the country.
These men frame their isolation as persecution by the Left. But it’s more than that: they have chosen a political movement whose leaders, donors, and judicial appointees openly want to roll back the rights that allow them to exist in public at all.
The friends they’ve lost didn’t leave because of a policy disagreement. They left because these men are helping elect people who would strip healthcare, legal recognition, and and protection from discrimination away from their loved ones.
The Rationalizations
The interviews reveal a consistent pattern of motivated reasoning. Duncan points to Scott Bessent and other gay figures in the administration as “proof” the GOP is not anti-gay.
He omits that Trump has appointed Supreme Court justices who have publicly called for overturning marriage equality, and Cabinet members, including Pete Hegseth, Marco Rubio, and Pam Bondi whose records on LGBTQ issues are openly hostile.
Hegseth claimed that allowing members of the community to serve openly in the U.S. Military was “following a Marxist agenda.” There’s that Commumarxisocialist attack again.
Marco Rubio said he doesn’t believe same-sex marriage is a Constitutional right and thinks sexual orientation is “a choice.”
Advocate says Pam Bondi “terrorized” LGBTQ+ Americans during her time as Trump’s Attorney General.
Doane offers a more disturbing justification, claiming that Muslim immigrants brought in by Democrats will “murder gays brutally with a smile on their face.” This is not a policy position. It is a recycled far-right talking point that uses gay men as rhetorical shields for xenophobia.
Research from the Brennan Center for Justice, which examined attitudes from 1984 to 2020, found that racial resentment is significantly more prevalent on the political right than the left.
Evan insists that there are only two genders, a view contradicted by peer-reviewed research, and he rejects the label “LGBTQ” in favor of being seen as “normal.”
This language tracks closely with Vice President JD Vance’s 2024 pitch on Joe Rogan’s podcast courting the “normal gay” vote, a framing that works by drawing a line between acceptable gays and everyone else in the community, particularly trans people.
President Trump made the idea that there are only two genders an “official policy” of the federal government. That’s part of Project 2025, the Christian Nationalist blueprint from the Heritage Foundation.
Can someone please teach our President the difference between “sex” and “gender”? Better yet, let’s fund the public education system so we can avoid the claim in the first place.
Throwing Trans People Overboard
The through-line in every interview is a willingness to trade trans rights for personal comfort. Duncan opposes what he calls “gender ideology” in LGBTQ spaces.
Doane believes trans people should not access gender-affirming care until adulthood and that trans women should be barred from women’s dressing rooms unless they have had surgery, a position that ignores both medical consensus and a 2025 study showing bathroom policing causes measurable mental distress in trans youth.
Duncan also supports restrictions on LGBTQ education in schools, echoing Florida’s “Don’t Say Gay” law, and argues that “a functioning society is built on a heteronormative bias.”
This is the bargain at the heart of gay MAGA men in politics: accept that you are the exception, agree that your community is a problem to be managed, and in exchange you get to feel normal.
It is a bargain the right has offered minority groups for generations. It has never ended well for the people who took it.
What They Don’t See
Duncan says marriage equality secured his rights permanently. It did not. Obergefell rests on a 5-4 precedent that multiple sitting justices have signaled they want to revisit.
Doane approves of Trump’s border wall and military interventions in Iran and Venezuela, and his main criticism of the administration is that it left Venezuela too quickly.
Duncan says he does not love the mass deportations but cannot think of another way.
These MAGA gay men describe themselves as satisfied customers of a political project that is actively building the legal and cultural infrastructure to reverse their civil rights.
They have traded community for belonging somewhere they are tolerated as long as they stay useful, and they call this freedom.
The loneliness they describe is real. It is also, in the most literal sense, a problem of their own making.
Everyone is welcome here. To become a free member of our community, there’s only one requirement—well, I guess technically there are two: Have an open heart and an open mind.
Race, ethnicity, gender, political ideology, a checkered past, etc. is irrelevant. Just don’t be a racist, a bigot, or use hate speech on Resisth8.com.
To put it simply: Be nice. We’re all human beings living together on the same planet.
“Can’t we all just get along?” 😉
Members of the LGBTQ+ community,
You are not alone. Resist Hate and the members of our anti-hate community support you and we are here for you.
If you are feeling alone, depressed, or hopeless, reach out and ask for help. It takes strength and courage to ask for help.
Visit our LGBTQ+ Resources page for more information and phone numbers you can call.